Four members of 36 Family appeared in a lengthy and complex fact-finding hearing within care proceedings, with the court’s findings described as being “of the utmost seriousness”.
Hannah Markham KC and Samantha Dunn, representing the Local Authority, alongside William Tyler KC and Meredith Major (instructed by Wilson Browne Solicitors), representing the child victim directly on his own instructions, secured findings of the utmost seriousness following a complex High Court fact-finding hearing.
Ms Justice Harris DBE found that A had been subjected by his mother to a prolonged and systemic “torturous regime”. He had been cut with knives and scissors, struck with poles, spanners and wooden planks, bitten, strangled, and forced to lie on the floor whilst his mother walked on him in high heels. The abuse caused multiple inflicted physical injuries and profound emotional harm to A. The Court also made findings that his mother had subjected him to sexual abuse and had exerted pressure on him to retract his allegations against her.
Securing those findings was critical not only for A, but for the protection of the entire sibling group. The Court found that the four younger children had been placed at risk of significant emotional harm by living in a household where their eldest sibling was being routinely abused in this way, with evidence that at least one sibling had been exposed to witnessing some of the physical abuse against A.
The case required highly skilled forensic analysis of extensive material including digital and contemporaneous evidence spanning a significant period of time, alongside the exceptionally sensitive presentation of A’s evidence following his retraction and subsequent reinstatement of the allegations. The findings exposed the true extent of the abuse within the family home and provided the evidential foundation necessary to protect all five children from further significant harm.
Ms Justice Harris DBE took the unusual step of publishing this judgment to assist all professionals working within the Family Justice System with understanding the correct approach that should be taken when investigating allegations of serious harm towards children. The Judgment further emphasised the need to carefully weigh wider canvas evidence that’s either inculpatory or exculpatory when considering allegations.
The welfare outcome for this case is soon to be published too as there were exceptional and complex circumstances that required careful consideration.
The judgment can be viewed here.
News coverage from Family Law News can be viewed here.
Further information
For more information from the family team, contact clerks@36family.co.uk







